Ethics In The Media – Assignment Example
Ethics in Media My selected source of media is Film which is “The Rain Man”. Directed by Barry Levinson, this movie has achieved 4 Oscar and another 19 awards (IMDb).
The Case: It is the story of two brothers - Raymond and Charlie, whose father is a rich man. The yuppie Charlie was thrown out of home by his father during his teenage because of a wrongdoing. After many years, Charlie came to know that his estranged father has died and left for him only a car and a bunch of flowers. He learns that his father has willed $3 Million to a medical trust, namely Walbrook Institute, which is to be received by someone whose name is Raymond.
Charlie goes to the trust to find out about the person and learns that Raymond, an autistic man, is his elder brother who has been kept in the trust because of his impaired mental situation. His father never told this fact to him. Raymond is capable of doing complicated mathematical calculation.
In order to achieve a share in money, Charlie abducts Raymond and blackmails the doctors to give him $ 1.5 Million. Later, Charlie takes Raymond to Las Vegas where Raymond helps Charlie in achieving $86,000 in gambling with his outstanding ability of calculation. At this point, there starts an emotional attachment between the two brothers. They reconnect. Attachment with Raymond teaches Charlie patience, kindness and tolerance. On the other hand, Raymond shows great improvement as a result of companionship with Charlie. They shares joke and make fun as well which greatly contributes in improving many of Raymond’s odd behaviors.
Now Charlie doesn’t want to loose Raymond. Doctors forces Charlie to give Raymond back even they offer $250,000 to him but he rejects and refuses to give Raymond back. Doctors exhibit Raymond’s impaired condition to Charlie and say that if Raymond is not kept under supervision of doctors, he might harm himself by involuntary reactions. The doctor Hearing this, Charlie finally unwillingly agrees to send Raymond back to the mental institution by promising Raymond that he will visit him frequently.
Ethical Issues: Charlie’s companionship with Raymond teaches Charlie the principle of toleration and principle of respect for persons. Charlie was previously a self-centered and rigid person but entrance of Raymond brought tremendous changes in his life.
His decision to send Raymond back Hospital depicts one of the basic principle of morality - principle of nonmaleficence which suggest not to harm anyone deliberately and advices to seek the patient’s good (ascensionhealth.org).
The principle of respect of autonomy, which implies that one should be provided self-determination, was hurt as doctors’ decision was deemed on Raymond to live in Hospital. Moreover, in hospital, Raymond would be suppressed and could not enjoy freedom.
Conclusion: I think doctors’ decision to keep Raymond in hospital would stop any further progress in Raymond mental health which was quite prominent when Raymond was with Charlie. I think that a better option would be to allow Raymond to live with Charlie with the supervision of some nurses.