StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In considering the ethical issues relevant to the ideas of honesty, justice, due process, and crime control, we are confronted by the radically divergent practicality of concepts that should be harmonious. It would be reasonable to expect, in a civilized society, that we can synthesize these elements without too much problem…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma"

Download file to see previous pages

Justice is sometimes served by dishonest acts. Similarly, the safety afforded the accused by due process can circumvent crime control and send the message that the punishment for criminal behavior is often escapable through manipulation of the system. This negates the deterrent value of effective law enforcement and implies that if criminals are smart enough, they can use the constitutional protections within the criminal justice system to escape punishment. The four elements must be balanced with their attendant ethical issues into a system that delivers justice and crime control without compromising honesty or due process.

There is a difference between honesty and justice, and we will consider a hypothetical situation in which dishonesty can actually serve justice. Honesty is defined as "the characteristic of being fair, truthful, and morally upright" (Encarta, 2005, n.p.) Justice, in terms of its application to the legal system, is characterized by "fairness or reasonableness. [in] the act of applying or upholding the law" (Encarta, 2005, n.p.). Thus, in the definition of both words, we have the idea being fair.

Ethically, this can provide a personal dilemma when the unfairness of an individual action results in accomplishing the fairness associated with the successful application of the law. For example, we can posit the example of an un-truthful act on the part of a law enforcement officer that results in the conviction of a guilty person. Let's say that a police investigator has spent months on the surveillance of a drug dealer. He or she knows that the individual is a drug trafficker as a result of watching their behavior over a long period of time.

When the time comes for an arrest, the perpetrator has no drugs on his person or in his vehicle; so the officer plants a small amount of heroin in the individual's possession to bolster the evidence needed for the arrest and conviction. Clearly unethical, the officer's actions are neither fair nor morally upright under the strict definition of honesty. Yet, in terms of the service of justice, the guilty drug dealer is convicted and taken off the streets. This is an ethical problem faced by law enforcement daily.

It is the application of honesty to justice and, for many in law enforcement, the ends justify the means. In other words, the technically dishonest act of the police investigator results in justice being served because the truly guilty perpetrator is convicted. Under ethical analysis, this is obviously wrong; yet, the inescapable conclusion is that justice has been served.Due Process and Crime ControlThe second set of considerations is related to due process and crime control. The idea of due process is to protect the rights of the accused and assure that there is no rush to judgment without the consideration of all the evidentiary factors in a case.

This idea has led to many rules and procedures within the criminal justice system that protect the accused. One of the fundamental tenets of the system is that it is better for the guilty to go free than for the innocent to be punished. As Roger Cossack's article notes, "Blackstone said many years ago

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay”, n.d.)
Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1523323-honesty-justice-due-process-and-crime-control-an-ethical-dilemma
(Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay)
Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1523323-honesty-justice-due-process-and-crime-control-an-ethical-dilemma.
“Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1523323-honesty-justice-due-process-and-crime-control-an-ethical-dilemma.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Honesty, Justice, Due Process, and Crime Control: An Ethical Dilemma

Water Weapons Officer

From this discussion it is clear that the Fundamentals of Canadian Defence Ethics presented the types of ethical dilemma in three general categories: the uncertainty dilemma which is of general nature but where no clear indication of right and wrong could be simply inferred; competing obligations dilemma, as the term indicates, the number of courses of action and decision complicate the selection since most are consistent with differing ethical values and obligations; and harm dilemma is a difficult ethical situation where a course of action or decision would result to injury or harm....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Is Justice for All Possible in America

In the paper “Is justice for All Possible in America?... rdquo; the author analyzes a risk to the concept of justice for all.... Given the diverse nature of the American society, availing justice for all members of society is an extremely difficult, if not impossible task.... This means that often, even the most effective of justice systems did not represent a large portion of humans living in the country (Schmidtz, 110)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Ethical Issues of Drug Program Evaluation

Exploring the ethical issues regarding a Program Evaluation Customer Name: University Name: Abstract The problem of drug abuse and illegal use of hazardous substances has always been a menace to mankind, causing various sociological and psychological disorders.... Although models for various drug courts depend upon their target population, resources and evaluation techniques they involve a general criterion such as: crime assessment and offender identification, judicial interaction and case management, monitoring procedures such as drug testing and supervision while on probation, courtroom procedures and eventually graduating sanctions, reward incentives or vice versa, providing ancillary treatment and services such as, mental health improvement, Stress and trauma related family therapy and vocational training, improved skills and over all enhancement of the quality of life....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Why it is Important for those in the Criminal Justice field to have good character

Name Law 8 October 2013 Why it is Important for those in the Criminal justice Field to have Good Character Introduction The professionals in the criminal justice field have always been under public scrutiny for their performance and the way they execute their roles.... … Name Instructor's Name Law 8 October 2013 Why it is Important for those in the Criminal justice Field to have Good Character Introduction The professionals in the criminal justice field have always been under public scrutiny for their performance and the way they execute their roles....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Honesty versus Justice or Due Process versus Crime Control

The main purpose of the due process is to protect the rights of the accused and it provides a system of safeguard that will help in combating the abuse within the law enforcers and the crime control model which promotes the reduction and elimination of crimes by the agents of law and the police.... Sometimes after detection of a certain crime, Justice and punishment are the most vital areas in international Justice and crime.... This paper also explains the due process model....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Designing Organizations to Create Value

The approach used by the managers to manage human resources determines the ethical value of their responsibilities.... Different ethical theories have been brought forward which depending on how they are applied can challenge the ethical value of human resource management.... The paper "Business Ethics" is a critical evaluation of human resource management from the perspective that it might be an unethical process....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Professionalism and ethics learning portfolio

A… c understanding of the philosophical context to the ethical issues in the legal profession reveals that the Hippocratic Oath is being considered because it sets forth an important adage in the practice of the medical profession which can admirably set to rights the current l issues in the legal profession: “First, do no harm.... Generally speaking, law is now guided by an established philosophical school: ethical egoism; that is, doing what is best for oneself is what is best for the world....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Is Justice Possible for All in America

This essay "Is justice Possible for All in America" focuses on the fact that availing justice for all members of society is an extremely difficult, if not impossible task, given the diverse nature of the American society.... hellip; justice is one of the basic principles that each democratic country tries to establish within its functioning.... America, like all countries that value the tenets of democracy, strives to provide justice to all individuals on American soil....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us